Dangerous defendants - a rejoinder

Hemming, Andrew ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1314-0737 (2019) Dangerous defendants - a rejoinder. UMKC Law Review, 87 (4). pp. 827-850. ISSN 0047-7575


In the January 2018 edition of the Yale Law Journal, Assistant Professor Sandra G. Mayson argued that an objective risk assessment instrument to determine whether bail should be granted provided the basis for applying the same risk standard to defendants and equally dangerous non-defendants. This is a startling proposition. In this rejoinder, it will be contended that reliance on a solely objective risk assessment is flawed and that equating the risk standard applied to defendants with non-defendants who are equally dangerous is fallacious. Risk assessment is both an objective and subjective exercise, which can be refined and recalibrated by the use of categories of offenses where the onus of proof differs depending on the seriousness of the offense (for example, the onus of proof as to why the defendant should be granted bail falls on the defendant where the charge is murder), and by the use of conditions in the granting of bail outside of posting money bail. These conditions address issues well beyond the one-dimensional risk assessment as to whether the released defendant will commit other crimes, as assumed in the article. Judges determining a bail application regularly engage in a balancing exercise between the competing public interests of the assumption of innocence and the protection of the public at large; this is hardly a quantitative formulaic task.

Statistics for USQ ePrint 36334
Statistics for this ePrint Item
Item Type: Article (Commonwealth Reporting Category C)
Refereed: Yes
Item Status: Live Archive
Additional Information: Published version cannot be displayed due to copyright restrictions.
Faculty/School / Institute/Centre: Current - Faculty of Business, Education, Law and Arts - School of Law and Justice (1 Jul 2013 -)
Faculty/School / Institute/Centre: Current - Faculty of Business, Education, Law and Arts - School of Law and Justice (1 Jul 2013 -)
Date Deposited: 21 May 2019 05:00
Last Modified: 28 Jan 2020 23:48
Uncontrolled Keywords: Dangerous defendants - objective risk assessment - bail - balancing exercise
Fields of Research (2008): 18 Law and Legal Studies > 1801 Law > 180110 Criminal Law and Procedure
Fields of Research (2020): 48 LAW AND LEGAL STUDIES > 4899 Other law and legal studies > 489999 Other law and legal studies not elsewhere classified
Socio-Economic Objectives (2008): C Society > 94 Law, Politics and Community Services > 9404 Justice and the Law > 940403 Criminal Justice
URI: http://eprints.usq.edu.au/id/eprint/36334

Actions (login required)

View Item Archive Repository Staff Only