Reasserting the place of objective tests in criminal responsibility: ending the supremacy of subjective tests

Hemming, Andrew (2011) Reasserting the place of objective tests in criminal responsibility: ending the supremacy of subjective tests. University of Notre Dame Australia Law Review, 13 (1). pp. 69-112. ISSN 1441-9769


This paper contends for a greater role for objective tests
on public safety grounds, and building on the measure of
objectivity contained in reckless murder at common law
and constructive murder in all Australian States, seeks
to redress the balance in favour of objective tests. The
argument is made for an objective test for recklessness
as the underlying fault element, based on the natural and
probable consequences test adopted in Director of Public
Prosecutions v Smith [1961] AC 290, which is similar to
objective ‘Caldwell’ recklessness where the defendant
does not foresee the relevant risk but a reasonable person
would have, following Caldwell [1982] AC 341. The paper
also advances the case for the adoption of purely objective
tests for provocation and self-defence, because the current
tests in Australia for both defences are confusing as they
combine subjective and objective elements.

Statistics for USQ ePrint 20705
Statistics for this ePrint Item
Item Type: Article (Commonwealth Reporting Category C)
Refereed: Yes
Item Status: Live Archive
Additional Information: This paper is available in AustLi, which is open access.
Faculty / Department / School: Historic - Faculty of Business and Law - School of Law
Date Deposited: 04 Feb 2012 00:52
Last Modified: 26 Aug 2014 22:33
Uncontrolled Keywords: criminal responsibility; objective and subjective tests; Caldwell recklessness
Fields of Research : 18 Law and Legal Studies > 1801 Law > 180110 Criminal Law and Procedure
18 Law and Legal Studies > 1801 Law > 180122 Legal Theory, Jurisprudence and Legal Interpretation
16 Studies in Human Society > 1602 Criminology > 160204 Criminological Theories
Socio-Economic Objective: C Society > 94 Law, Politics and Community Services > 9404 Justice and the Law > 940403 Criminal Justice

Actions (login required)

View Item Archive Repository Staff Only