Differences between systematic reviews/meta-analyses of hyaluronic acid/hyaluronan/hylan in osteoarthritis of the knee.

Campbell, J. and Bellamy, N. and Gee, T. (2007) Differences between systematic reviews/meta-analyses of hyaluronic acid/hyaluronan/hylan in osteoarthritis of the knee. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage, 15. 1424-1436 . ISSN 1063-4584

Abstract

Objective: To explore reasons for discrepant results between systematic reviews (SR)/meta-analyses (MA) of the efficacy and safety of hyaluronic acid/hyaluronan/hylan (HA) therapy in the treatment of osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee. Methods: A decision algorithm was utilised to identify reasons for discordance among six SR. Sources of discordance such as clinical question, trial selection and inclusion, data extraction, assessment of study quality, assessment of the ability to combine trials, and statistical methods for data synthesis were examined. Results: A similar question was asked in all six SR. Different trials were selected for inclusion in the reviews mainly because of differences in the search strategies and selection criteria. Although similar methods for data extraction were utilised, differences were found both in the outcome measures and time-points selected for extraction. Methodological quality was not always formally assessed. Different statistical methods for data synthesis resulted in conflicting estimates of therapeutic effect. Conclusions: Reasons for the inconsistency of results reported in the six SR were identified. Using the principles of the GRADE approach for estimating the therapuetic effect of HA in the treatment of OA of the knee, there is moderate evidence suggesting that further research is unlikely to change our confidence in the estimate of the effect. In the balance of benefit to harm, the trade-off is probable benefit with respect to pain reduction and physical function improvement with low risk of harm.


Statistics for USQ ePrint 7775
Statistics for this ePrint Item
Item Type: Article (Commonwealth Reporting Category C)
Refereed: Yes
Item Status: Live Archive
Additional Information: Author version not held.
Depositing User: Dr Travis Gee
Faculty / Department / School: Historic - Faculty of Sciences - No Department
Date Deposited: 02 May 2010 04:14
Last Modified: 02 Jul 2013 23:51
Uncontrolled Keywords: hyaluronan; hyaluronic acid; hylan; knee; meta-analysis; osteoarthritis; systematic review
Fields of Research (FOR2008): 11 Medical and Health Sciences > 1103 Clinical Sciences > 110322 Rheumatology and Arthritis
Socio-Economic Objective (SEO2008): C Society > 92 Health > 9201 Clinical Health (Organs, Diseases and Abnormal Conditions) > 920116 Skeletal System and Disorders (incl. Arthritis)
Identification Number or DOI: doi: 10.1016/j.joca.2007.01.022
URI: http://eprints.usq.edu.au/id/eprint/7775

Actions (login required)

View Item Archive Repository Staff Only